City of Promisesby Victoria Thompson
and Ellen Thompson
ISBN-13: 9780593816516
Hardcover: 336 pages
Publisher: Berkley
Released: July 28, 2026
Source: ebook review copy from the publisher through NetGalley.
Book Description, Modified from Goodreads:
Famed former police detective turned private investigator Frank Malloy and his wife, Sarah, come to Gideon Bates desperate for legal guidance. The Malloys’ adopted daughter, Catherine, a burgeoning star of the stage, has announced her engagement to a man she barely knows. Catherine has recently gained access to her trust fund, and Sebastian Talbot appears very eager to marry her as quickly as possible.
As Gideon and his wife, Elizabeth, investigate, it becomes all the clearer that Talbot may not be who he says he is. As a former con artist herself, Elizabeth suspects one may be in their midst. Undeterred by her pregnancy, she must pull out all the stops to save another woman from ruin.
My Review:
City of Promises is a historical set in 1920 in New York City. This is the 8th book in the series, and it also included the characters from the Gaslight Mysteries, 20 years later from their timeline. Catherine has grown up, become a famous actress, and she let slip that she had inherited money. A con man has her convinced she's found true love, and no one thinks she believe them if they simply confirm he's a con man (which Elizabeth does) and tell her. So Elizabeth set up this overly complicated "con" where another woman catches the con man's attention to divert him from Catherine.
While I enjoyed the fun story, it seemed like the characters lost focus on what they were about at times. We got a funny sequence about Elizabeth trying out to play in films. Elizabeth could have just asked various actresses about how much film actresses made, or, really, that whole section could have been removed without anyone noticing. It ended up playing no role in the actual "con." Also, her brother Jake was an experienced con artist, yet he kept getting distracted mooning over the married woman playing the rich widow decoy. Mother Bates somehow changed from a strong suffragist to drinking gin (during prohibition and behind her son's back) to calm her nerves.
The historical details were woven into the story to create a sense of the specific time and place and brought the story alive. There was no sex or bad language. Overall, I'd recommend this entertaining historical novel.
If you've read this book, what do you think about it? I'd be honored if you wrote your own opinion of the book in the comments.





