
A Fatal Crossing
by Tom Hindle
ISBN-13: 9798217185740
Paperback: 464 pages
Publisher: Dutton
Released: July 28, 2026
Source: ebook review copy from the publisher through NetGalley.
Book Description, Modified from Goodreads:
November 1924. The Endeavour sets sail from Southampton carrying 2,000 passengers and crew on a week-long voyage to New York. When an elderly gentleman is found dead at the foot of a staircase, and the ship's captain is ready to declare it a tragic accident. But James Temple, a strong-minded Scotland Yard inspector, is certain there is more to this misfortune than meets the eye.
Ship's officer Timothy Birch agrees to investigate, and the trail quickly leads to the theft of a priceless painting. Its existence is known only to its owner and the dead man. Temple and Birch's search for the culprit is hurried as just days remain until they reach New York and more bodies are added to the count.
My Review:
A Fatal Crossing is set in 1924 on a death boat. Er, cruise ship. I had so many problems with this book, but the first is that I read mysteries to see justice done. Every bad person in this story (murderer, thief, or just looking away when a rule was broken or crime committed) walked away free, no justice done, and with a pile of bodies left in their wake.
The characters weren't likable, either. The British police officer was rude, mean, and disdainful toward everyone, even the captain of the ship. Ship officer Birch seemed incompetent from the beginning, and he's stupid. For example, a knife taken from the restaurant was found in the room where the painting was stolen and became evidence. Birch later had a sharp object pressed against his side by someone who would never have been allowed in the restaurant (his earlier conclusion) but he thinks the object must be that same knife. Logic need not apply. Birch also repeatedly said he'd report this or do that but then we skip ahead and he hasn't.
The mystery made no sense. It started with the premise that a famous painter who only painted landscapes was rumored to have painted a portrait. An artist thinks he's found the painting even though an experienced art dealer didn't think it was anything special. But the artist is going to try to sell the painting--which few art buyers think even exists--at a big art show everyone's going to. People found out about it and practically everyone tried to steal it with the intent of then selling it at the art show. Um, first, stolen property can't be sold openly! Second, even the owner would have to explain how he got the painting and have art experts examine the painting and decide if it's a fake or not. Third, we find out that the painting was taken out into pounding rain so bad that one couldn't see where they were going. It had to have gotten wet, which would destroy a watercolor painting, then it was stored in a place (which I guessed!) and in a way that would have prevented it from drying out properly, thereby ruining the painting even if it was an oil painting. But not only is the stolen painting not an actual portrait but it's in perfect condition. Sigh.
Finally, our detectives were stupid. The police officer took one look at the body in the morgue and concluded he must have been pushed off the top of the steps, hit his head, and died. I could think of several other ways the man could have a head wound on the back of his head and be found at the base of the stairs. Later, the police officer accepted that his theory of whodunit was wrong and gave up because he couldn't think of anything else to ask or do. I'm thinking, um, here's a long list of questions you never asked and clues you never followed up on. Birch even tasked a porter with looking into a matter only to completely forget to follow up with the fellow. This was a long, frustrating read.
At about 80%, I came up with a scenario which fit all of the clues and would have been a satisfying, classic mystery. I knew it wasn't the author's solution, which turned out to be so convoluted and unbelievable I thought, 'well, of course no one would guess this.' I did guess the twist in the last 10%. Ruined the whole story. And the ending was left open-ended as to if that action led to the hoped for result.
There was a fair amount of bad language. There was no sex. Go read a classic mystery and leave this on the shelf.
If you've read this book, what do you think about it? I'd be honored if you wrote your own opinion of the book in the comments.





