
Pride and Practicality
by Pepper Basham
ISBN-13: 9780840717719
Paperback: 368 pages
Publisher: Thomas Nelson
Released: November 3, 2026
Source: ebook review copy from the publisher through NetGalley.
Book Description, Modified from Goodreads:
Thomas Bridges, the new rector of St. Groves, has a simple plan: gain the support of local wealthy parishioners to finance a boarding school for the orphans of St. Groves. With his stellar reputation and good heart, everything seems to be working well, even if he has to avoid his mother's matchmaking with the eligible ladies of the town. But his plans are rerouted when the "lost" sister of Lord Ravenscross returns and she happens to be the same woman in which he shared a secret and unexpected kiss eight months before.
Arianna Reeves has returned home a secret heiress, trying to redeem her past. With money to spare, a desire to earn back the favor of those she loves, and a hope of being useful she not only puts herself in harm's way to help the children of St. Groves but creates an "anonymous benefactress" to support Thomas Bridges' plan. However, their mutual attraction threatens to not only defrock Thomas but also ruin all their best-laid plans for the children.
When a man from Arianna's past comes to St. Groves with a plan to expose Thomas and Arianna's secret, their future together seems impossible.
My Review:
Pride and Practicality is a lust-motivated romance set around 1814 in England. However, the main characters were very modern in their attitudes so it didn't feel true to the period. I mean, Arianna rudely told off Thomas' uncle (whom she needed to impress to marry Thomas) and thought this would be the way to win him over. She was rude to a lot of people due respect and felt justified. Anyway, Arianna at least didn't try to hide that she'd made the choices that led to her ruin, but she also proudly refused to try to repair her reputation. She wouldn't even take a companion with her when visiting the rough sections of town and brothels. Rather than learning from her past, she actually encouraged Thomas to kiss her and welcomed it.
Thomas viewed himself as so much more morally pure than his fellow clergymen, yet he fell in lust at first kiss (taken in a dark garden with a woman he didn't know, which may have started accidently but sure didn't end that way). When he met Arianna again, he was constantly thinking about kissing her, nearly kissing her in public (thus making their reputations worse), then kissing her every chance he got, including in a dark closet. By the end, he's willing to give up his calling as a rector so he can bed her. He knows so little about her and has no plans for how he can support her (as he doesn't know she's rich), but that didn't matter.
And don't tell me he loved her: he helped her by sending her off to a compassionate rich woman and never followed up to find out if she made it or how she was doing. When they met again, he didn't try to find out much about what had happened (like who her seducer was, which caused problems later). She had no respect for him. She wouldn't follow his advice, no matter how sensible, and would stubbornly fight with him for no real reason. He'd just think about how that passion would be in the bedroom. Her own brother warned him she'd always be stubbornly defying him but, hey, the making up afterward would make it worth it! Seriously? This is a "Christian" book? No wonder we have so many divorces.
There were no sex scenes (though plenty of passionate kissing scenes). There was no bad language.
If you've read this book, what do you think about it? I'd be honored if you wrote your own opinion of the book in the comments.





