
These Blue Mountains
by Sarah Loudin Thomas
ISBN-13: 9780764242021
Paperback: 352 pages
Publisher: Bethany House
Released: July 15, 2025
Source: ebook review copy from the publisher through NetGalley.
Book Description, Modified from Goodreads:
German pianist Hedda Schlagel's world collapsed when her fiancé, Fritz, vanished after being sent to an enemy alien camp in the United States during the Great War. Fifteen years later, in 1932, Hedda is stunned to see Fritz's name in a photograph of an American memorial for German seamen who died near Asheville, North Carolina. Determined to reclaim his body and bring closure to his ailing mother, Hedda travels to the US. Her quest takes a shocking turn when, rather than Fritz's body, his casket contains the remains of a woman who died under mysterious circumstances.
Local deputy Garland Jones thought he'd left that dark chapter behind when he helped bury Fritz Meyer's coffin. The unexpected arrival of Hedda, a long-suffering yet captivating woman, forces him to confront how much of the truth he really knows. As he works to uncover the identity of the woman in the casket and to unravel Fritz's fate, Hedda and Garland grow closer. But with Hedda in the US on borrowed time while Hitler rises to power in Germany, she fears she'll be forced to return home before she can put the ghosts of her past to rest.
My Review:
These Blue Mountains is set in 1932 in Germany and North Carolina. I hesitate to call it a romance since only Garland seemed slightly in love. Hedda came to the USA on a temporary visa to retrieve her dead fiancé's body only to discover that he wasn't in the grave and that she didn't want to return to Germany. She overstayed her visa. Even though Garland told her she'd be deported since she didn't meet any of the exceptions for extending her visa, she went ahead and tried to anyway with a predictable result. She seemed to like Garland and her other potential love interest (who mainly wanted a German-born mother for his teen son), but she was completely content being single and teaching piano lessons. When Garland offered to marry her so she could stay, she laughed.
It wasn't until it was clear Garland really cared about her--and she really wanted to stay in America--that she suddenly decided she might love him. Someday. Also, she wanted to continue teaching at the college where her friends were, but Garland lived in a different town. This issue was skipped over (as well as the details about how they got legally married and the visa issue fixed). The epilogue simply showed a happily-ever-after ending.
That said, I enjoyed this as a historical. It was an interesting look at how people in Germany and the USA felt about the rise of Hitler and the changes that brought. Also, how non-combatant Germans had been detained at the beginning of WWI and about the village they made in a detainment camp located in the area. It showed how people might end up illegally in the USA and uncertain how to make things right without getting deported to a country that no longer felt safe. (It wasn't advocating illegal immigration, just used it as a way to increase suspense. Though it did bother me that law enforcement officers knew her illegal status and didn't push her to make things legal quickly.) While Garland did investigate the mystery, that was more an excuse for Hedda to stick around than the focus of the story. There was no sex or bad language. Overall, I'd recommend this interesting historical novel.
If you've read this book, what do you think about it? I'd be honored if you wrote your own opinion of the book in the comments.