The Missing Maid by Holly Hepburn

The Missing Maid
by Holly Hepburn

ISBN-13: 9781835337394
ebook: 219 pages
Publisher: Boldwood Books
Released: March 27, 2024

Source: ebook review copy from the publisher through NetGalley.

Book Description, Modified from Goodreads:
London, 1932. When Harriet White rebuffs the advances of her boss at the Baker Street building society where she works, she finds herself demoted to a new position… a very unusual position. Deep in the postal department beneath the bank, she is tasked with working her way through a mountain of correspondence addressed to Baker Street’s most famous Mr Sherlock Holmes.

Seemingly undeterred by the fact that Sherlock Holmes doesn’t exist, letter after letter arrives, beseeching him to help solve mysteries, and Harry diligently replies to each writer with the same Mr Holmes has retired from detective work and now lives in Sussex, keeping bees.

Until one entreaty catches her eye. It’s from a village around five miles from Harry’s family estate, about a young woman who went to London to work as a domestic, then disappeared soon afterwards in strange circumstances. Intrigued, Harry decides, just this once, to take matters into her own hands. And so, the case of the missing maid is opened…


My Review:
The Missing Maid is a mystery set in 1932 in England. No one is murdered. It started off fine, with a well-born gal working as a secretary at a bank deciding to solve a case sent to Sherlock Holmes (because the bank is located at the fictional address). She posed as Holmes' secretary when dealing with the missing girl's family. She asked questions and followed up on leads, though mostly she seemed to stumble upon the needed information. She realistically made mistakes along the way, including not being very convincing in a disguise. Things started to become less and less realistic, though. The missing maid showed back up, but she's accused of theft. Again. Harry's determined to prove the maid's innocent.

At least one modern phrase was used. When questioning the girl, the maid never mentioned that the girl who took her in looked exactly like her yet Harry immediately assumed she was the look-alike girl. Harry put on trousers for the first time and hid her hair, and suddenly she had everyone convinced she's a man. The author implied she stunk and people moved downwind to avoid it, but they'd want to move upwind, and why is there a wind in an enclosed space? When in disguise, she walked off with a beer mug from a bar, and no one objected or found it odd that she was carrying it around in the streets. She could throw corrugated iron sheeting some distance yet couldn't figure out how to deal with her captive without help. Yet Oliver (who was helping her) could not only do it alone but came up with a way to pass the evidence on to the police. She's the one who insisted on doing a citizen's arrest, yet she hadn't thought all that through? And then she decided to type up her adventures like a Sherlock Holmes story while on bank time. Huh. Not to mention, why did the thief twice hide the jewelry under Mildred's pillow so she'd get caught if the game was to use her to allow the true thief to walk out of the house with the stolen goods? As in, the true thief never benefited from this complicated look-alike game.

There was no sex or bad language.


If you've read this book, what do you think about it? I'd be honored if you wrote your own opinion of the book in the comments.