In Pursuit of Civility by Jennifer Turano

In Pursuit of Civility
by Jennifer Turano

ISBN-13: 9780764243868
Paperback: 304 pages
Publisher: Bethany House Publishers
Released: April 21, 2026

Source: ebook review copy from the publisher through NetGalley.

Book Description, Modified from Goodreads:
Annaliese Merriweather has been appointed the temporary headmistress of the Merriweather Academy for Young Ladies while her sister is on her honeymoon, but she doesn't feel cut out for the role. Especially after she loses two of her most troublesome students during an outing to a county fair and has to recruit the help of Seth McCormick, an eccentric inventor, to retrieve them.

Soon after, one of those mischievous students disappears again, intent on pursuing a pirate map. Together, Annaliese and Seth set out to find her, accompanied by a menagerie of Annaliese's rescued animal companions. As they stumble from one chaotic situation to the next, sparks fly between Annaliese and Seth.


My Review:
In Pursuit of Civility is a romance set in 1885 in Chicago. This has the typical quirky characters that stand out from the crowd, and I did enjoy Seth. He's thoughtful and paid attention to what Annaliese said, giving her a spiders, for example, rather than a more typical gift. And this won her heart. They're both clearly in love with each other before halfway through, and the only thing holding up a wedding is that Annaliese is worried Seth wants a traditional wife. Just ask him, girl, as it's not like he acts like he's interested in traditional women!

My major problem with this book was the author avoided writing action scenes as much as possible, so little happened "on screen." It's people talking about what's going on, repeating what was just said (maybe even just a sentence ago), or talking about the funny action that just happened "off screen." Wordy, wordy, wordy, and instead of witty it just got tedious.

I also found Annaliese exasperating rather than funny. She meant well but she so often caused the problem she was trying to solve. Like taking 13-year-old girls to a fair (not known as a place for high manners) to practice their manners. Or allowing a 13-year-old who ran away to go treasure hunting (a reward) instead of going home with an adult. Or being willing to pay animal abusers a huge amount of money to acquire their animals when those people would just use that money to buy more animals, thus feeding the trade she's trying to stop. I just couldn't respect her.

The missing aunt prayed to God for rescue, and Annaliese's group "just happened" to learn her whereabouts, which she attributes to answered prayer. There was no sex or bad language. This is the last Jennifer Turano for me. I needed a laugh, but this wasn't it.


If you've read this book, what do you think about it? I'd be honored if you wrote your own opinion of the book in the comments.